The cozy Italian restaurant Il Cantinori is the setting for many a romantic NYC evening, and June 18 was no exception. But seated among the canoodling couples was one surprising duo: Jennifer Aniston and The Hangover star Bradley Cooper. "We put them at a secluded table in the back," one Il Cantinori staffer tells Life & Style.

The pair arrived around 10 p.m. and left two hours later. "They were very flirty and into each other -- it was definitely a date," says an eyewitness. "Jen looked really happy. When they left, they went back to the same hotel together!"

For more on Jen and Brad's date, pick up the latest issue of Life & Style Weekly, on newsstands now!

Photo Credit: Startraks