The blonde beauty ended up choosing Jerry Ferris over John Paul Merritt, but ultimately rejected his proposal. Even though she wanted to see where the relationship would go, the pair didn't survive the four months between filming and the live After the Final Rose special. The publicist went on to marry Joe Waterman in May 2009, and they have two daughters, Mae Elizabeth and Charlotte Grace.
Getty Images, Facebook
Keep up with Ali Fedotowsky in the pages of Life & Style by subscribing now!