While we love having the opportunity to continue seeing the ever-adorable “Grocery Store Joe” Amabile on our TVs, it’s pretty clear that Bachelorette runner-up Blake Horstmann should be the one battling it out on Dancing with the Stars. On Oct. 5, he proved his skills once again by twirling Kaitlyn Bristowe around to Britney Spears‘ “You Drive Me Crazy”!

He was at a winery in Nashville recording an episode of Kaitlyn’s Off The Vine podcast in front of a live audience with Tia Booth and Brandi Cyrus, and at one point they all began dancing. Much to her surprise, Blake ended up straight-up flipping Kait upside-down, and the crowd went wild!

Clearly, Blake is proud of his skills. He took to Instagram Stories to share like five fan recordings of his performance. But he did a lot more than just dance while he was there. Kaitlyn teased the upcoming episode, writing, “Last night’s panel was ?? We danced, we confessed, (some of the best confessions I’ve heard), we sang, we WENT THERE, and I cannot wait for you guys to hear it on Tuesday.” Neither can we!

Kait wasn’t the only one who got to spend some time with the Bachelorette heartthrob. Her fiancé Shawn Booth also hung out with Blake, inviting him to a training session at his BoothCamp gym! “I only threw up in my mouth once and I was sweating more than the Maldives ?,” he captioned a sweaty pic. “Had a first timer in class today… Making him earn those drinks tonight! Thanks for working out with the #BCAMPteam,” Shawn captioned his own photo. 

View this post on Instagram

Smooth @balockaye.h (really should’ve been on #dwts 😩)

A post shared by All_Things_Bachelornation (@all_things_bachelornation) on

Many fans thought that Blake would be asked to star on DWTS after he left Bachelorette empty-handed and broken-hearted. Videos had surfaced of Blake getting his groove on while in a hotel filming the show, and even giving some of his fellow contestants swing lessons. He may not have been selected, but hey, there’s always next year! 

Love The Bachelor? Keep up with the fun by joining our Facebook group!