Juan got the shock of his life when the 32-year-old hairstylist from Sacramento, Calif., showed up sporting a baby bump. Clare said she knows he has a daughter and that he wants more kids, before asking Juan to feel her belly. She admitted it wasn't real, but wanted to play a joke on the girls inside. Juan's thought? She's "very cute." Something tells us most guys would consider that crazy. But Juan Pablo is not most guys. Juan, just take your shirt off already. Thanks.
See who's still in the running to possibly become Mrs. Juan Pablo Galavis!