Lesson #1: don’t try to pull a fast one on Rachel Lindsay because she will embarrass you on social media! One woman learned that the hard way when she shared a photo with The Bachelorette‘s recently rejected suitor, Dean Unglert.

In a play on the Colorado native’s controversial opening line, “I’m ready to go black and I’m never gonna go back,” Instagram user lauren_gonz captioned her pic with the 26-year-old, “Went black, but came back.” Dean, whose relationship to the blonde remains unknown, responded, “Lololol at the caption” with a couple of 100 emojis.

But we doubt the mystery Instagrammer expected Rachel herself to reply to the post. The 32-year-old hilariously wrote, “Sent back…he didn’t come back lol.” YAS, GURL! We couldn’t have crafted a more perfect response.

EXCLUSIVE: ‘Bachelorette’ Rachel Lindsay Comes off as a “Total B—h” on the ‘Men Tell All’ Special

Fans were left shocked on July 17 when the attorney sent the adorable startup recruiter home after meeting his family. In a blog post for People magazine, the Texan explained her decision. “I cried on the entire flight to Dallas, and I cried all day leading up to it,” she shared. “But when my tears dried I realized that, while I do feel a love for Dean, I’m just not sure he’s in a place in his life where he’s ready to settle down and start a family in the near future.”

She added, “I still think he’s figuring himself and his feelings out. It was a tough goodbye — he was defensive, confused and a bit angry… I prayed that night the he wasn’t leaving this relationship believing I judged him based on meeting his family. I only judged him on if he was ready for the same things I am.”

Despite their difficult goodbye, it looks like Dean has already moved on. It’s been confirmed that the third runner up will appear on Season 4 of Bachelor in Paradise, which premieres on Aug. 14. We don’t doubt that he’ll be popular with the ladies!

Love The Bachelorette? Be sure to join our Bachelorette Facebook group to chat about all the latest updates, exclusive interviews, and juicy gossip!