Bachelor Nation Engagement Rings Ranked by Carat Size: See Who Has the Biggest Sparkler!

Demi Burnett & Kristian Haggerty — 2 Carats

Fans swooned over Demi Burnett and Kristian Haggerty‘s engagement because their love seemed so genuine. The contestant from Colton Underwood‘s season got down on one knee during the Paradise season 6 finale and received an astounding “yes” from her partner. Later, during the aftershow, Kristian returned the gesture and proposed to Demi in front of the live audience. Sadly, the two announced their split in October 2019.

“Kristian’s trendy engagement ring appears to feature a 2-carat emerald cut diamond set horizontally (also referred to as an east-west setting) on a unique split shank, diamond-accented band in white gold or platinum,” Kathryn Money, VP of Strategy & Merchandising for Brilliant Earth, exclusively dished to Life & Style. “Depending on the quality and specific characteristics of the center stone, we estimate the cost of the ring between approximately $20,000 to $30,000.”

For all you Neil Lane fanatics out there, get ready to drool over the ring from Kristian. “Demi’s glamorous engagement ring appears to feature a 2.25 princess or radiant cut diamond. Her white gold or platinum setting features diamond accents on every angle of its band adding extra sparkle,” Kathryn noted. Depending on the specific qualities of the center stone, the blonde beauty’s new piece of jewelry could cost anywhere between “$25,000 to $35,000.”

Krystal Nielson & Chris Randone — 2 Carats

From villains to a fan-favorite couple, Krystal Nielson and Chris Randone got engaged at the end of season 5 of Paradise after bonding over baby hairs and green juice. Aw! One year later in summer 2019, they officially walked down the aisle. Unfortunately, they announced their split to “work on themselves” eight months later. The Goose picked out a gorgeous pear-shaped diamond on a platinum setting weighing in at two carats.

Katie Morton & Chris Bukowski — 2.25

Despite a beautiful engagement during the finale, Katie Morton confessed that she was “exhausted” and her “tank was empty” because of her relationship with Chris Bukowski during the aftershow in September 2019. However, the couple agreed to work on their romance because they thought it was worth saving. Katie left that sit down wearing her gorgeous engagement ring from the reality stud.

Depending on the size and quality, the price of Katie’s dazzler is estimated to be between “$35,000 to $45,000.” Kathryn of Brilliant Earth divulged to Life and Style, “Katie’s show-stopping engagement ring appears to feature a 2.25 to 2.5-carat round brilliant cut diamond in a white gold or platinum setting featuring 12 additional diamond accents.”

These two fizzled out three months after he got down on one knee. They officially announced their breakup in December 2019.

Ashley Iaconetti & Jared Haibon — 2.4 Carats

If you want to feel hopeful about love, look no further than Ashley Iaconetti and Jared Haibon. After crushing on him for three years, she finally got the guy! They got engaged at the Paradise beach during summer 2018 and were married in Rhode Island on August 11, 2019. Ashley I. said she “always wanted a princess radiant cut with a small band and a nice big stone.” Jared delivered and added an 86-diamond halo around the stone.

They welcomed son Dawson in January 2022, and are expecting the arrival of baby No. 2!

Hannah Godwin & Dylan Barbour — 2.5 Carats

Hannah Godwin and Dylan Barbour fell head-over-heels during season 6 of Paradise. Despite a momentary love triangle with Blake Horstmann, the two were attached at the hip their entire stay and got engaged during the finale. One thing is for sure: The sparkler Hannah received was fit for their real-life fairytale.

“Hannah’s stunning engagement ring appears to feature a 2.5-carat cushion cut diamond surrounded by a halo of 20 round diamonds in a delicate platinum or white-diamond accented setting,” Kathryn from Brilliant Earth, exclusively told Life & Style. “Depending on the quality and specific characteristics of the center stone, we estimate the cost of the ring between approximately $30,000 to $40,000.”

The couple tied the knot in a dream wedding at the Chateau de Villette in Condécourt, France, in August 2023.

Katie Thurston & Blake Moynes — 2.5 carats

Contestant Blake Moynes proposed to leading lady Katie Thurston during the finale of season 17 with a gorgeous ring. They may have split, but her ring is still major.

The impressive center stone, which is set on a platinum band, is a “2 to 2.5-carat oval diamond,” Kathryn Money, Brilliant Earth‘s SVP of Merchandising and Retail, estimates to Life & Style. In addition, the jewelry expert said the sparkler also appeared to have “1.5 to 2-carats in hidden gallery accents.”

“Hidden accents on a delicate band can typically only be seen in profile and offer a unique way to add a little extra sparkle to a ring,” Kathryn explained. “It’s also a great way to give the center stone a lift and is more subtle than a traditional halo setting.”

Kathryn estimated Katie’s ring costs between “$25,000 and $50,000,” depending on the quality and specific characteristics of the center and side stones.

Hannah Brown & Jed Wyatt — 3 Carats

Hannah Brown and Jed Wyatt had one of the shortest engagements in the franchise after the musician got down on one knee during The Bachelorette finale. The Alabama beauty ended things when she realized he lied about the extent of his relationship with his ex Haley Stevens. Their relationship ended roughly but she did have an incredibly gorgeous (and large) ring.

“Hannah’s ring appeared to feature an oval cut diamond accented by a halo and set on a delicate, white gold or platinum diamond-accented band,” Kathryn Money, VP of Strategy & Merchandising for Brilliant Earth, exclusively explained to Life & Style. The gem expert added, “Depending on the quality and specific characteristics of the diamond, we estimate the cost of the ring to be between $45,000 to $80,000.”

Hannah has since said “Yes” to current fiancé Adam Woodlard after the former model popped the big question in August 2023.

Johnny Dephillipo & Victoria Fuller — 3 Carats

The “classic platinum three-stone diamond ring” weighs between “3 to 4 carats” and has an estimated cost of $25,000 to $40,000 Brilliant Earth’s Kathryn Money told Life & Style about Victoria Fuller‘s engagement ring from Johnny DePhillipo. They broke up shortly after his proposal during the season 8 BiP finale, which makes the meaning behind the ring even more heartbreaking.

“The oval diamond center stone is a trending shape while the three-stone style alludes to the traditional metaphor of past, present and future,” the jewelry expert explained.

Brandon Jones & Serene Russell — 3 Carats

Brandon Jones had no reservations about proposing to Serene Russell during season 8 of BiP. The impressive sparkler is an estimated “2. 5 to 3 carats,” Brilliant Earth’s Kathryn Money, told Life & Style about the “yellow gold solitaire diamond ring set with a beautiful emerald cut center stone.”

The ring, which also features a “hidden halo and additional hidden diamond accents” is estimated to be worth between $50,000 and $80,000.

After almost one year together, Serene and Brandon ended their engagement.

Bryan Abasolo & Rachel Lindsay — 3 Carats

The queen of all Bachelorettes Rachel Lindsay got engaged to her dream man, Bryan Abasolo, at the end of season 13. Rachel’s 3-carat, pear-shaped diamond is so lovely. The rock sparkles within a platinum setting.

The two seemed to be endgame until January 2024 when Bryan shocked fans by filing for divorce from Rachel.

Michelle Young & Nayte Olukoya — 3 Carats

The couple got engaged during The Bachelorette season 18, but they announced their split in June 2021 after one year together.

Michelle’s ring is “diamond and platinum ring centering a pear shape diamond set with 2 tapered baguette diamonds and further set with 46 round brilliant cut diamonds for a total weight of over 3.00 carats,” per Us Weekly.

Zach Shallcross & Kaity Biggar — 3.10 Carats

Zach Shallcross got down on one knee and proposed to Kaity Biggar with a 3.10 carat Neil Lane ring, according to People. 

“It’s like a huge disco ball,” Kaity gushed to the outlet of the sparkler.

Rachel Recchia & Tino Franco — 3.25 Carats

Season 19 star Rachel Recchia‘s engagement to Tino Franco didn’t last long after he proposed during the finale, but the ring was absolutely stunning.

The center diamond was supported by a hidden halo of 24 smaller round diamonds in addition to the detailing of eight yellow diamonds featured around the large stone, according to People. The 3.25-carats sat atop an 18-carat gold band.

Gabby Windey & Erich Schwer — 3.25 Carats

Similarly to Rachel, co-leading lady Gabby Windey received a 3.25-carat engagement ring from her now-ex-fiancé, Erich Schwer, during the season 19 finale.

The oval-cut center stone, which featured eight small yellow diamonds around the perimeter, was supported by a hidden halo of 22 smaller round diamonds, per People. The 18-carat gold band perfectly fits the stylish ring.

Less than two months after fans watched Erich get on one knee, the couple went their separate ways.

Tayshia Adams & Zac Clark — 3.5 Carats

“Tayshia’s beautiful ring appears to feature a 3 to 3.5 carat emerald-cut diamond surrounded by a diamond halo and set on a white gold or platinum diamond adorned band,” Kathryn Money, VP of Strategy & Merchandising for Brilliant Earth, exclusively told Life & Style, estimating the design costs between  $45,000 and $75,000.

Although Zac and Tayshia’s engagement ended, her ring is still one of the most gorgeous in franchise history.

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Shawn Booth — 3.5 Carats

Kaitlyn Bristowe‘s round-cut diamond from Shawn Booth was unique because of the twisted band encrusted with 160 smaller stones. Neil Lane said he created the ring for Kaitlyn and had a feeling she would end up wearing it.

This longtime couple revealed that they broke up at the beginning of November 2018. However, we’ll look back at her $150,000 ring fondly.

Peter Weber & Hannah Ann Sluss — 3.5 Carats

Peter and Hannah Ann lasted for even less time than Hannah and Jed! Peter picked Hannah Ann after Madison Prewett quit, but then he dumped Hannah Ann to go after Madi … then they split. After the finale, he began dating Kelley Flanagan and they embarked on an on-again, off-again relationship until they broke up for good in early 2023.

Still, the ring was gorgeous while it lasted. “Hannah Ann’s stunning ring features an estimated 3 to 3.5-carat pear-shaped diamond surrounded by a diamond halo and set on a diamond-adorned platinum or white gold band,” Kathryn Money, VP of Strategy & Merchandising for Brilliant Earth, exclusively told Life & Style, clocking the dazzler at “$40,000 to $80,000.”

Arie & Lauren — 3.65 Carats

A second proposal, a second ring. Arie Luyendyk Jr. may have gotten backlash from fans for re-proposing to runner-up Lauren Burnham, but Neil Lane was happy to make a new stunning ring. Neil Lane admitted that the cushion-cut center stone that sits snuggly between two baguette diamonds surrounded by 170 other sparkling stones was “the most intricate ring” he’s ever designed. The two tied the knot in January 2019 and welcomed their first child, a daughter named Alessi Ren, in May 2019. Lauren gave birth to their twins, son Lux and daughter Senna, in June 2021.

Arie & Lauren’s Ring No. 2 — 6 to 8 Carats

“Lauren’s beautiful ring appears to feature a 6 to 8-carat oval diamond set on a delicate diamond accented white gold or platinum band,” Kathryn Monday, SVP of Merchandising and Retail for Brilliant Earth, told Life & Style about the couple’s second engagement ring. The expert estimates the cost of the ring is “between approximately $150,000 to $300,000.” 

Desiree & Chris Siegfried — 3.7 Carats

Desiree Hartsock and Chris Siegfried got engaged during season 9 of The Bachelorette. The low-key couple tied the knot in 2015.

The rose-gold touches in Desiree’s cushion-cut diamond and platinum ring give it a vintage vibe. Chris got her a rose-gold wedding band to match. So chic!

Jordan Rodgers & JoJo Fletcher — 3.75 Carats

Jordan Rodgers and JoJo Fletcher got engaged during season 12 of The Bachelorette. The adorable couple lives in Dallas, and they share two dogs. They originally planned to walk down the aisle in June 2020 but had to postpone amid the coronavirus pandemic. They walked down the aisle in June 2022. What does a $100K ring look like? Look no further than the 3.75-carat oval stone with over 155 surrounding diamonds on JoJo’s finger. Nice work, Jordan!

Jordan Rodgers & JoJo Fletcher — New Ring

After they had been engaged for a few years, Jordan re-proposed to JoJo in 2019 while they shopped for wedding venues. And she received a major ring upgrade!

“JoJo’s stunning engagement ring upgrade appears to feature a 5 to 6-carat oval cut diamond in a timeless solitaire yellow gold setting,” Kathryn Money, VP of Strategy & Merchandising at Brilliant Earth told Life & Style at the time. “Depending on the quality and specific characteristics of the center stone, we estimate the cost of the ring at approximately $150,000 to $250,000.”

Becca Kufrin & Garrett Yrigoyen — 3.76 Carats

Becca Kufrin and Garrett Yrigoyen have one of the most impressive rings in the history of the show.

Becca’s gold band definitely stands out from the others. On top of her ring sits three oval stones. Two of the stones represent Becca and Garret and the other is their future together. That future was cut short when they split following tons of controversy in summer 2020.

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Jason Tartick — 4 Carats

In May 2021, Kaitlyn and Jason Tartick announced their engagement after over two years of dating. “The ring looks to be a 4-carat oval diamond,” Zaven Ghanimian, CEO of family-owned jewelry brand Simon G. Jewelry, exclusively told Life & Style. “The style is a straight line diamond pave setting with eagle claw prongs. The minimal design is clean and timeless with nice details under the center diamond setting.”

The couple revealed in August 2023 that they ended their engagement. They quietly split and shared it with close family and friends before sharing the news to the public.

Ben Higgins & Lauren Bushnell — 4.25 Carats

One of the biggest rings in the Bachelor franchise sat on the finger of Lauren Bushnell. The couple broke up after a year and a half proving that love don’t cost a thing. The blonde beauty is now married to country singer Chris Lane and they have two children together. Ben, meanwhile, married Jessica Clarke in November 2021.

Clare Crawley & Dale Moss — 5 Carats

Clare touted that she knew what she was looking for from the beginning of her season, and she proved that by walking away a few weeks later with Dale. Sadly, their whirlwind romance didn’t last.

The Neil Lane sparkler put the other Bachelor Nation rings to shame with size and weight. “Clare’s stunning, art deco-style engagement ring appears to feature an estimated 4 to 5-carat radiant cut diamond, framed by two accent diamonds and set on a diamond-adorned platinum band,” Kathryn Money, SVP, Merchandising & Retail Expansion for Brilliant Earth, told Life & Style following their engagement episode in November.

Depending on the specific quality and characteristics of the stones, Clare’s ring is estimated to cost between “$100,000 to $150,000.”

The couple’s rocky relationship came to an end in September 2021 and Clare is now married to husband Ryan Dawkins.

Charity Lawson & Dotun Olubeko – 3 Carats

Charity Lawson and Dotun Olubeko quickly became Bachelor Nation’s purest love story after he proposed to her during the season 20 finale ​in 2023

Dotun chose a gorgeous oval-shaped bling ring with a band that featured small diamonds.