It’s a match made in ABC heaven! Bachelorette alum Wells Adams and Modern Family star Sarah Hyland are reportedly dating. The duo sparked rumors after dressing up in coordinating costumes this Halloween after weeks of flirting on social media.

Wells, 31, went as Eleven from the Netflix series, while Sarah, 26, dressed up as Dustin. “Stranger things have happened #happyhalloween,” she captioned the pic. And while it may come as a surprise to Bachelor Nation, the couple is said to be casually dating and have been “seeing each other for months, a source told Us Weekly.

View this post on Instagram

#strangerthings have happened #happyhalloween

A post shared by Sarah Hyland (@sarahhyland) on

Sarah confirmed she split from boyfriend of two years Dominic Sherwood on Twitter earlier this month, writing, “The problem with being single isn’t the fact that you’re alone. It’s that you can’t puppy dog eye a guy into getting you Starbucks in bed.” However, she seems smitten with Wells.

Earlier this summer, Wells tweeted, “Taking applications for #BIP5 bar backs now. Please send references… Preferably from Phil Dunphy. I’m kidding the job is yours @sarahyland,” and Sarah was quick to respond. “I’ll start working on my garnishing skills. Oh and I require 35% of your tips…. or free dogs,” she tweeted. An Eagle-eyed Reddit user also noticed that Wells and Sarah were seemingly taking a selfie from the same room, proving they are getting serious.

sarah hyland wells adams instagram

He also admitted on a podcast that he was seeing someone in LA and spending a lot of time there. We guess things fizzled between Wells and his Bachelor in Paradise co-star Danielle Maltby following their steamy kiss on the reality dating competition.

“We are just friends right now,” the radio DJ said. “If things progress romantically, we’re going to take our time with that and not worry about the show or Twitter or anything like that trying to make us something that we’re not ready to be.”

Love The Bachelor? Be sure to join our Bachelor Facebook group to chat about all the latest updates, exclusive interviews, and juicy gossip!