Well, this is awkward. Caitlyn Jenner was one of the panelist’s at We tv’s Dec. 11 Real Love: Relationship Reality TV’s Past, Present & Future panel to celebrate the Love After Lockup premiere, but it was what went on post-panel that had people talking. According to an eyewitness at the afterparty, people kept thinking Cait was with one of the Kardashian girls when they saw her talking to rumored girlfriend Sophia Hutchins.

“Caitlyn was in a corner with Sophia, who looks just like a Kardashian,” revealed the onlooker to Life & Style. “People commented that they kept thinking it’s Khloé or Kim. Her face work is obviously designed around a Kardashian.” And while Cait was more than happy to do the panel, she seemed anxious to leave the party after a short while. “They were drinking wine, but not much, did a couple of photos, and left,” the source continued.

Getty Images

Cait looked beautiful for the evening. She was rocking her long locks straight for the night, and she wore a fabulous black dress with fur-lined sleeves. She topped the look off with some simple black heels that showed off her legs. Sophia wore a trendy black and white power suit with black pumps, and wore her sleek blonde hair straight. It’s easy to see why the Kardashian comparisons are happening: between her killer lashes, plump pink pout, and chic outfit, she would fit right in with the family!

Interestingly, Cait was at the event to speak as a “Relationship Reality Expert along with people like Bachelorette Rachel Lindsay and Tori Spelling, which kinda makes sense, and also kinda doesn’t. Of course, her marriage to Kris Jenner crumbled on Keeping Up with the Kardashians, but she was also in a TV relationship for nearly a decade and there were many outside factors — including her transition of course — that affected her marriage.

Getty Images

Cait’s life after her transition was documented on her show I Am Cait, where Sophia played a big role in helping show her the ropes of being a new woman. It looks like she’s more comfortable in her skin than ever!