There’s a serious love triangle happening over a hunky man on Bachelor in Paradise!

Contestants AshLee Frazier and Clare Crawley are both fighting over Graham Bunn.

But there’s a catch! Life & Style has exclusively learned that AshLee and Graham used to date, prior to filming.

“Secretly, Graham wants AshLee back,” an insider dishes to Life & Style. But that didn’t get in the way of Clare asking Graham on a date. “All Clare does is cause drama!”

For more inside details from Bachelor in Paradise, pick up the new issue of Life & Style, on newsstands now.