He may not have been a household name before his time on The Bachelorette, but that doesn’t mean that Colton Underwood had never stepped into the spotlight. Way before he strolled the beach looking for love on Bachelor in Paradise or found himself cast as the new star of The Bachelor, Colton was stepping out onto red carpets left and right. No, not because of his football career — though we’re sure being in the NFL opened plenty of doors, too. He was stepping out with his then-girlfriend, Olympian Aly Raisman. Check out the gallery below to see pictures from their relationship.