Is the simulation broken? On January 31, Kim Kardashian took to Twitter to share a picture of her hubby, Kanye West, casually celebrating fellow rapper Kid Cudi’s birthday … but that’s not all. The father-of-three, 41, was joined by SNL comedian and occasional foe Pete Davidson, as well as, Oscar nominee Timothée Chalamet.

On an individual basis, each of them has a special connection to Cudi, 35. In fact, Pete, 25, once said that Cudi’s music “saved his life.” However, all of them getting together sort of feels like trying to hang out with your high school and college friends at the same time. It’s a good idea in theory, but in execution? Er, not so much. Naturally, the internet agreed with that sentiment and decided to share their unsolicited opinions.

“Is it just me, or did no one else expect these four people to be in the same room together?” one user commented. “I am confused as to why these four are in the same room,” echoed another. In addition to the general feeling of “WTF is going on?” … a lot of other people were equally as perturbed by the lone bottle of Fiji water on the table. Of course, having water at a restaurant is hardly unsettling, but the fact that it was being chilled in what appeared to be a custom Fiji water chiller, well, that’s too much wealth to process for the average person.

At the end of the day, it looks as though Pete, Timothée, 23, Kanye and Cudi all had a fantastic time. We mean, Mr. Yeezy himself is even smiling in one of the photos. How often does that happen? TBH, We’re not exactly itching to see this foursome get together again, but it will definitely go down as an interesting moment in celebrity history.