When Reality Worlds Collide! See Which Reality Stars Dated Each Other From Different TV Shows

Carly Lawrence and Bennett Sipes

The Too Hot to Handle and Love Island alums tied the knot in May 2022 after only five months of dating.

Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo

The Winter House and Summer House stars were destined to mingle within the Bravo world. Oddly enough, that’s exactly what they did after announcing their relationship in October 2021 after sparking romance rumors months prior. 

“It was done in a healthy way. We built a friendship and got to know each other first, and it all happened naturally,” Craig told People at the time. “You see the foundation of our relationship start to form on the show.”

Nikki Bella and Peter Kraus

After getting out of a six-year relationship with professional wrestler John Cena, the Total Bellas twin went on a date with The Bachelorette alum Peter Kraus. Nikki’s twin sister, Brie Bella, initiated the date to get her sister back in the dating game in 2019.

Blake Horstmann and Giannina Gibelli

Their time on reality dating shows didn’t work out for them, but a party show sure did! The couple revealed via People in November 2023 that they were expecting their first child together.

Stephanie Pratt and Derek Peth

Bachelor in Paradise bartender Wells Adams set these two up on St. Patrick’s Day in 2019, which resulted in a three-month relationship. After going their separate ways, Stephanie revealed that her life was “too much drama” and didn’t want to include Derek in her life complications.

Nikki Bella and Artem Chigvintsev

The cutest reality television mashup! The WWE wrestler and dancer were partners on Dancing With the Stars in 2017 but didn’t start dating until nearly two years later. Artem and the Total Bellas star welcomed their son in July 2020 and are preparing to wed finally in fall 2022.

Scheana Shay and Robby Hayes

Unfortunately, it wasn’t all happening for these two.