Halsey Makes Red Carpet Debut With New Boyfriend Evan Peters at ‘American Horror Story’ Party

Get you a man who will go full Halloween costume with you for your red carpet debut. Singer Halsey and her new boyfriend, Evan Peters, did just that when they made their first public appearance as a couple for the first time at the American Horror Story 100th episode celebration on October 26. The recent couple seriously served as Cher and her late ex-husband, Sonny Bono.

Evan, 32, wore an all-white suit look, complete with a shaggy brown wig and an over-exaggerated ’70s mustache. Halsey, 25, rocked a super sexy white dress with rainbow polka dots and Cher’s famous long, straight hair (most likely also a wig). Clearly, this couple wanted to make a pretty ~groovy~ statement for their first step out as a duo.

Things are still pretty new for the pair, but they definitely seem really into one another. A source confirmed to Us Weekly that Evan and Halsey had been seeing each other quietly for several weeks on September 28. Days before, they were spotted holding hands at Six Flags Magic Mountain theme park in Los Angeles — causing speculation to rise with fans.

Even more recently, the twosome was spotted packing on the PDA at a restaurant on October 20. “Halsey and Evan were at Sweet Butter Cafe in Sherman Oaks,” the insider told Us Weekly about their coffee date. “They definitely looked like a couple. They were eating together and Halsey was laughing throughout their lunch. When they walked out of the restaurant they were hugging each other.”

Believe it or not, the Grammy nominee (real name: Ashley Frangipane) has actually harbored a crush on the actor for quite some time now. “Seriously Evan Peters stop making me attracted to alleged sociopaths and accused murderers,” she tweeted in November 2012.

Two years later, the singer tweeted yet again about her love for the often-spooky actor. “I’m a f—king liar I’m so in love with Evan Peters I’m so whipped I’m whipped as f—k!” she wrote in 2014. Not for nothing, she also had a mega crush on Harry Styles back in her pre-fame days, so we’re glad one of her celeb crushes actually panned out. You go, girl.

Scroll through the gallery to see photos of Halsey and Evan’s red carpet debut!