Nicole “Snooki” Polizzi and Nico Tortorella’s new show How Far Is Tattoo Far? premieres Thursday, Oct. 11 after Jersey Shore Family Vacation, and judging by the exclusive sneak peek above, it definitely brings the drama. In the clip, tattoo artist Travis shows Snooki the design Melody has chosen for her friend Dakota, and it’s “f—ed up” (his words, not our’s).

“Oh my god!” Snooki responds after seeing the design. “She likes like?” “Yeah,” Meolody quips. “[But] it’s a secret.” Yikes! 

Check out the drama in the clip above and don’t forget to tune into the show Oct. 11 at 9pm on MTV.