All you need to get Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux’s attention is a cute baby! Life & Style can exclusively reveal that the duo, who tied the knot in a private ceremony back in 2015, are totally consumed with baby fever. On Sept. 30, the duo dropped by Emilio’s Ballato in NYC for dinner with another couple. Jen ordered a martini with olives and the table shared an antipasto, but Jen and Justin were easily diverted from their meal when they caught sight of a fellow patron’s 16-month-old.

“They seemed to have baby fever,” the diner tells Life & Style. “When I picked up my son, Justin pointed at him and motioned to Jen, and she turned around to smile at him.” Neither Jen nor Justin, 48 and 46 respectively, have children of their own, but from the sound of things, that might change soon! “They seemed to be so smitten at the sight of children,” the source adds.

While this may be true, Jennifer has opened up in the past about the world’s obsession with her personal life. In an interview with Vogue over the summer, Jen talked about the body-shaming she goes through as a woman in Hollywood.

“I’ve shifted my perspective, so who gives a s–t!” she told the mag. “If you’re going to walk out and have your nipples showing, or your belly is a little bloated, or you’re not at the weight you want to be — you are perfect no matter what you are and no matter where you are and who cares!”

Well, we think these two would make awesome parents. And talk about passing on good genes — that baby would be totally stunning!

For more exclusive celebrity news, pick up the latest issue of Life & Style, on newsstands now.