It looks like Bachelor in Paradise worked its magic for alum Juelia Kinney — and she’s not even in the cast. The Bachelor alum just revealed she is dating Aaron Bass, who happens to be Evan Bass’ brother.

In case you need a refresher, Juelia’s BFF Carly Waddell is married to Evan, and judging from a sneak peek of the nuptials Juelia met her new man at their wedding, which was filmed for BiP. Bachelor Nation just keeps getting smaller and smaller.

MORE: Does Raven Gates Find Love in ‘Bachelor in Paradise’? We Have the Spoilers!

“He’s tall, he’s handsome, he makes me laugh, and most of all, he knows how to order my sushi,” she captioned a photo with her boyfriend on Instagram. Fans quickly congratulated the single mom, who has been looking for love on the reality series since Chris Soules‘ season in 2015.

“So so happy for you,” one follower wrote before another added, “I’m so happy for you! I’ve followed your journey on Bachelor and you truly deserve this!” Even executive producer Elan Gale left a red heart emoji under the photo. Unfortunately for us, Aaron’s social media is private so not much is known about him.

Juelia was last linked to Bachelor alum JJ Lane after the pair appeared on Season 2 of Paradise. “What started as a tremendous friendship has grown organically and both of us are very happy and excited,” JJ said at the time. While their romance was short lived, Juelia never lost hope in the process.

MORE: ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ Spoilers — Everything You Need to Know About Season 4!

“Paradise works, and it’s just so nice to see,” Juelia said in a sneak peek of Carly and Evan’s wedding. “It warms my heart. All the people here are so in love with Carly and Evan and it couldn’t be a better setting. It’s just a beautiful, beautiful time.”

Love Bachelor in Paradise? Be sure to join our Bachelor in Paradise Facebook group to chat about all the latest updates, exclusive interviews, and juicy gossip!

To see where all your favorite Paradise couples are today, check out the gallery below!