The tea is nonstop when it comes to The Hills: New Beginnings cast! Spencer Pratt made a wild claim that he believes Justin Bobby is Audrina Patridge‘s real baby daddy, and we’re shook.

“Audrina and Justin Bobby had some crazy chemistry,” he told Cosmopolitan in an interview published on Tuesday, June 25. “What was all that talk about Justin Bobby doing things to Audrina her husband never did? I wanna know who’s baby that is. How do we know it’s not Justin’s Baby? Let’s get a DNA testing kit for the reunion. Get a whole lab in there for a dramatic reveal.”

The Hills Cast
Paul Zimmerman/WireImage

It looks like Spencer, 35, is #TeamJustin because he recognizes Justin, 37 has the potential to be the ideal match for the 34-year-old brunette— even after all these years. “There’s a Justin that would be great for Audrina. I’m not sure he’s ready to be that Justin yet,” he told the outlet.

Despite the fact that he seems supportive of their relationship, Spencer isn’t a fan of Audrina. “As much as Heidi [Montag] loves Audrina, every time I look at her, I still see her standing next to [Lauren Conrad] going, ‘You know what you did! You’re brainwashed, Heidi!'” he added. “Heidi says we would have done the same thing if our jobs were on the line, but I’m still working on moving past that. I always carry a crystal when we film together. Heidi says, ‘We needed her to come back,’ but she’s in pageant mode right now.”

Back in the original series, which aired from 2006 to 2010, Heidi, 32, was best friends with Lauren, 33, until she began dating Spencer. LC believed Spencer spread mean rumors about her, which made things awkward between her and Heidi, who stood by her then-boyfriend’s side.

Lauren’s time on The Hills came to an end at the end of season five after she attended Speidi’s wedding. Therefore, it’s not shocking she decided to not join her cast mates this time around. Though we miss her, this season looks like it’s going to be so good!