With only a handful of girls left on The Bachelor, we’re getting closer to finding out who Arie Luyendyk Jr. picks — but after looking through contestant Bekah Martinez‘s Instagram, we’re starting to think she isn’t the one. A video posted on Jan. 9 has us thinking the much-talked about 22-year-old accidentally spoiled her standing on Season 22.

In the clip, we see footage from an earlier episode that shows Arie and Bekah making out on the steps of the Bachelor mansion. “When we kissed, it was just apparent that she could be the whole package,” the race car driver says. But then the camera pans from the TV to Bekah in her apartment giving serious side-eye and looking almost disgusted.

View this post on Instagram

i could be the whole package

A post shared by BEKAH MARTINEZ (@whats_ur_sign) on

So, does this mean Arie breaks the California native’s heart? Why would she be rolling her eyes if she scored an engagement ring from the 36-year-old?

On Facebook, one viewer pointed out that Bekah’s recent missing persons case could signal that she doesn’t make it to the final four. “If Bekah’s mom thought she was a missing person, then does that mean she never had a hometown visit?” the astute fan asked.

As Life & Style previously revealed, Bekah was reported missing on Nov. 18 by her mother, who told the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office that her daughter had gone to work on a marijuana farm in the area. “[The mother] had phone contact with Bekah via a friend on the 12th,” Public Information Officer Samantha Karges said. “Bekah had told her she was coming to Humboldt County to work on a marijuana farm and she wouldn’t be able to contact her for a week or so.”

But, according to Reality Steve, Arie’s hometown dates were filmed between Oct. 26 and Nov. 1 — nearly three weeks before her mom reported her missing, so she still could have brought Arie home to meet her family. Bekah later joked about the whole debacle on Twitter, writing, “honestly the scariest thing about this story is that my efforts to conceal The Worst Drivers License Photo Of All Time have been thwarted.”

We’ll just have to wait and see if our suspicions are right! Until then, be sure to join our Bachelor Facebook group to chat about all the latest updates, exclusive interviews, and juicy gossip!