Peter Kraus, who is currently competing for Rachel Lindsay’s heart on Season 13 of The Bachelorette, used to have a major crush on one of the ABC dating show’s former stars — yep, none other than Season 10’s leading lady, Andi Dorfman.
According to screenshots taken by a reddit user, the 31-year-old personal trainer took to Facebook in February 2015 to let his friends know that he was nominated to be on The Bachelorette — and that he thought Andi, 30, was the total package.
“Sharing this because I was nominated to be on the next installment of Bachelorette,” Peter wrote at the time, accompanied by a link to an E! News story detailing Andi’s split from Josh Murray. “I would most likely never do it, but if this girl was on it, I might have to seriously reconsider.”
When one of Peter’s Facebook friends asked him if he ever watched Andi’s season, he replied, “I did not. I’ve honestly never seen a single episode of any of them, but she’s a cutie!”
The hunky fitness enthusiast’s online pal then told him that Andi is “not a nice person,” to which he responded, “Oh. Well, damn. Nevermind that idea.”
While he claimed to have never once tuned into The Bachelorette, it seems as though Peter has definitely been a longtime fan of The Bachelor. In his 2005 high school yearbook, obtained by TMZ, the Wisconsin native said that his future plans include “[being] on The Bachelor.”
Despite his past infatuation with Andi, Peter recently told Entertainment Tonight that he has super strong feelings for Rachel.
“I feel like we’ve had a good connection since the very start,” he told the outlet last month. “With Rachel’s it’s an instant connection — I mean it’s not hard to connect with someone who’s that intelligent, sophisticated, adventurous, outgoing, all that. She’s really all those things you kind of look for in a partner, so it was easy to fall for her real quick.”
Can’t wait to find out if Peter gets Rachel’s final rose? Check out the spoilers here.
To see Peter’s sexiest shirtless moments, click through the gallery below!
1 of 9
2 of 9
3 of 9
4 of 9
5 of 9
6 of 9
7 of 9
8 of 9
9 of 9