If you love happy endings, you’ll get a kick out of this news. Bachelor Nation has come full circle and there’s a new romance blossoming between The Bachelorette fitness hottie, Peter Kraus, and Bachelor in Paradise‘s resident spice queen, Bibiana Julian. If your jaw just hit the floor, fear not, we’ll explain everything.

Recently, some eagle-eyed fans (love you guys!) spotted Bibi and Peter in the background of a Miami Heat and Orlando Magic basketball game. The two can only be seen on-screen for a few seconds but they definitely looked cozy. Peter even had his hand on Bibi’s knee which, by body language standards, means they’re totally into each other.

A source confirmed to E! News that the basketball game was, in fact, a date and the two are a very new couple. “There is definitely a romantic connection there and they are casually dating,” the source said. “It’s very new and they are seeing how things go. They spent time alone in Miami together, went to the Heat game on a date, and are really enjoying each other’s company.”

So, how did this happen? The two have actually known each other for a little while now thanks to their new-found reality TV fame. The source said, “Peter and Bibiana have been friends for a while now through the Bachelor franchise, but most recently started hanging out alone.” While this couple didn’t cross our minds before, they are definitely cute together.

However, Peter lives and has a business back home in Madison, WI while Bibi resides in Miami, FL. The source divulged, “It’s hard because their relationship is long distance, but they are trying to see how things pan out and are definitely into each other.”

Not going to lie, we’re a little sad to see our favorite Bachelor hunk get taken off the market, but it couldn’t be by anyone we love more than Paradise‘s resident therapist, Bibiana. Best of luck, you two!