American Idol goes New York! Three of your favorite Real Housewives of New York stars have been romantically linked to season 4 contestant Constantine Maroulis after the August 13 episode of the hit Bravo series. Let us break it down for you.

While on their girls’ trip in Mexico, Luann de Lesseps pulled out her phone to show Ramona Singer a photo of an American Idol contestant — dubbed a “winner” by Lu, 55 — she dated. Ramona, 63, immediately revealed she went out with him, too, as did former cast member Tinsely Mortimer.

Marion Curtis/Starpix/Shutterstock

“We share a lot of people, don’t we?” the Ageless by Ramona founder told the Countess. “I went out with him. I know him well. Been there, done that. So has Tinsley!”

Naturally, production censored the singer’s name — so fans were quick to do some detective work. “OK, people. Who were the ladies just talking about?” one user wrote on Twitter. “An Idol winner Luann, Ramona and apparently Tinsley slept with?! They bleeped his name out? I’m dying to know!”

“The streets are saying the girls are Eskimo sisters with Constantine Maroulis,” another fan piped up. Finally, a third user sourced a photo of the three women posing with the 44-year-old, seemingly confirming it was him Luann referenced.

Constantine’s rep confirmed to Us Weekly the Brooklyn native has, in fact, been romantically involved with the three New York Bravolebrities.

“The ladies certainly were discussing Constantine on RHONY last night. They were probably listening to his new album,” the rep explained to the outlet. “Constantine Maroulis’ relationship with Tinsley was well documented several years ago. Constantine performed with Luann as part of her holiday tour last year and has enjoyed a friendship with Ramona as well. Constantine has great love and respect for them, considers each of them dear friends.”

The Rock of Ages star appeared on Tinsley’s first reality series, High Society, in 2010. He also showed up in the background of a season 7 RHONY episode and attended Bethenny Frankel‘s Skinnygirl Cocktails launch in 2015 — either of which could explain how Ramona and Luann got acquainted with the vocalist.

Either way, it looks like the ladies have been ~singing~ Constantine’s praises for a hot minute!