Someone special showed up to Demi Lovato‘s 25th birthday party on Sunday, Aug. 20, and fans could hardly contain their excitement! While showing off photos from her bash at Dave & Buster’s in NYC on her Instagram story, eagle-eyed followers spotted the singer’s ex-boyfriend Wilmer Valderrama posing next to her in the photo booth.

“I want nothing more in life than for #DemiLovato to get back together with Wilmer. I don’t wanna live in a world without them making babies,” one Twitter user wrote. Watch the video below to see the pic!

As Life & Style previously reported, the couple split in June 2016 after six years of dating. “This was an incredibly difficult decision for both of us, but we have realized more than anything that we are better as friends,” Demi and Wilmer, 37, said at the time. “We will always be supportive of one another. Thank you to everyone who has offered us kindness and support over the years.”

So are they still just friends? We guess time will tell!