That’ll turn a good day bad real quick! Poor Shay Mitchell took to Instagram on April 17 to reveal that she suffered a nasty accident earlier the same day — one of her teeth fell out while eating a bagel sandwich! Luckily, her amazing dentist Dr. Kevin Sands (who is also Kim Kardashian‘s doc) was able to fix her up quickly, but it made for a hilarious video in the meantime! Watch her struggle in the clip above.