Once again, social media has ruined The Bachelor for us! One eagle-eyed fan recently observed that both Arie Luyendyk Jr. and his winner posted to their Instagram stories from the same location — even though the lady in question tried to pretend that she was #graming from a different state. Check out the incriminating evidence in the video below, and for more info on who Arie picks, take a look at our spoilers here!

This isn’t the first time that a franchise lead has accidentally announced their winner before the finale. Season 11 Bachelorette Kaitlyn Bristowe posted a Snapchat showing her hanging out in bed with fiancé Shawn Booth well before the last episode aired. Though she quickly deleted it, the damage had already been done.

kaitlyn bristowe snapchat

And former Bachelor contestant Astrid Loch — who appeared on Nick Viall’s season — previously gave away Rachel Lindsay’s winner, Bryan Abasolo, in an interview. “They are going to Dallas to have a party there. He gets to meet all of her friends and non-Bachelor people too. And then they’re going to Miami after that to have an engagement party there too,” she said before the finale aired, revealing that Bryan, who’s from Miami, was Rachel’s pick.

C’mon, people. Let’s do better. Love The Bachelor? Be sure to join our Bachelor Facebook group to chat about all the latest updates, exclusive interviews, and juicy gossip!