We’ve got a repeat offender, y’all! On Dec. 6, Bachelor Nation babe Ashley Iaconetti sat down with Chris Harrison to spill all the good tea on what to expect from Colton Underwood’s season of The Bachelor.

As it turns out, however, Ashley knew something that Chris didn’t! *Gasp.* While speculating which lovely lady is going to show up dressed as a sloth (ahem, Alex D.), the pair gets to talking about all the, er, interesting costumes over the years — including the ever-legendary Cupcake (AKA Chris Strandburg from Kaitlyn Bristowe’s season of The Bachelorette.)

Chris Strandburg
Getty Images

Believe it or not, Chris’s hysterical meltdown during Season 11 didn’t prevent him from finding (temporary) love. “Speaking of Cupcake, one of the girls has dated Cupcake!” Ashley revealed to Chris. “And I think she may have been one of the pageant girls… I think it was Hannah,” Ashley mused.

Even though there are two girls named Hannah this season, we know for sure which one Ashley is referring to. Based on the job descriptions of all the Bachelor gals, Hannah B. is currently Miss Alabama 2018 in addition to being an interior designer. So, if Ashley’s intel is correct, Hannah dated Cupcake!

ABC/Craig Sjodin


That said, there’s more than one beauty queen for Colton to choose from this season. Caelynn is Miss North Carolina 2018! Sigh. The plot thickens. TBH, based on completely surface-level assumptions, we’re actually leaning toward Caelynn. After all, Kaitlyn was brunette during her season and Chris was *pretty* obsessed with her.

ABC/Craig Sjodin

Here’s hoping that once the season airs, we get the confirmation we so greatly deserve on this pressing matter. As for Cupcake? Well, we hear he’s doing just fine as a dentist… and no longer dressing like dessert on national television (or elsewhere).

Love The Bachelor? Keep up with all of the drama by joining our Facebook group!