This is the most dramatic season of The Bachelor and it hasn’t even started yet! Colton Underwood is a virgin, but fans are convinced that his potential wife might be with child from his new Instagram post, which showed him next to the pregnant girl emoticon. Wait, what?

The former football player wrote, “Date night with my babe. She’s a little pixelated tonight, but I promise you that she has a great personality. Thank you @nuggets for hosting.” One user quipped, “You got her pregnant already? Damn.” While another echoed, “Interesting preggo emoji choice…could this be a hint?” And my personal favorite, “Chris Harrison out here not providing protection for his fantasy suites.” Even Chris Randone from Bachelor In Paradise got in on the drama! He commented, “So pissed. Was looking forward to a spoiler-free season. And she’s pregnant. #LFG #NotAVirginNoMore.”

We’ve got some bad news for you though, Bachelor Nation. His ~mystery~ date was revealed later that night when Blake Horstmann posted an Instagram video of the two of them together at the hockey game. Blake wrote, “Sorry to disappoint you America, but I’m @coltonunderwood’s plus one.” The two laughed off rumors that were swirling online from earlier that night.

Blake Horstmann and Colton Underwood at a hockey game

The 26-year-old was in love with former Bachelorette, Becca Kufrin, before trying to make it work with Tia Booth on Bachelor In Paradise. Since Colton was filming the new season of The Bachelor up until recently, he is now back on social media, but obviously can’t say if he is he engaged or not.

In September, Colton was very excited to start his journey to find love. He told People, “I’m very excited. I’m so grateful. I can’t tell you how much I’ve been smiling.” He continued, “I can’t say enough good things about Becca and enough good things about Tia. They’ve helped me grow and discover who I am and what I’m looking for in a wife.”

We can’t wait for this season to begin — only 40 days left, but who’s counting?