We want to know, too! Kendall Jenner finally got to ask Harry Styles the question she’s been “dying” to know: Which of his songs were written about her? The exes appeared on The Late Late Show with James Corden on December 10 while the former One Direction stud was guest hosting. The model (and all of us watching) were keeping our fingers crossed for some good tea about his last album but sadly were left wanting.

The two were playing a game of “Spill Your Guts or Fill Your Guts” where you have to answer a question or eat something gross. The Keeping Up With the Kardashians star, 24, chose cod sperm as the alternative for her daring question 25-year-old.

“I’m dying to know this,” Kenny confessed. “Which songs on your last album were about me?” After looking at the gross food, the musician jokingly contemplated answering the question but opted to ~fill his guts.~

Although he wouldn’t dish the details, fans popularly believe that “Only Angel” and “From the Dining Table” were influenced by the reality starlet. The gorgeous A-listers were first romantically connected in 2013 when they were photographed together in New York, London and Los Angeles. Things seemingly started up again in 2016 after they were seen enjoying dinner at Ysabel in L.A. Needless to say, fans can’t get enough of their adorable chemistry.

Kendall Jenner and Harry Style Previous Relationship
Nick Harvey/Shutterstock

The “Lights Up” artist did seemingly confirm that he wrote some songs about the supermodel during a 2017 interview with Rolling Stone. He confessed that his music at the time was “tipping a hat to [their] time together.” He explained, “Sometimes you want to tip the hat, and sometimes you just want to give them the whole cap … and hope they know it’s just for them.” While the singer didn’t specifically mention Kendall by name, people were able to fill in the blanks for themselves and come to their own conclusions.

All in all, people were here for the reunion between the on-again, off-again exes. “Harry and Kendall looking at each other is insane,” one person gushed on Twitter. “Harry and Kendall are so happy and comfortable when they’re together I love them,” someone else echoed. “Always in love with the way Kendall looks at Harry,” another user added.

It looks like Harry likes to leave some things a mystery!