That’s what he thinks. Bachelor alum Nick Viall spoke with Life & Style exclusively about Bachelor Nation faves Peter Weber and Hannah Brown — and believe it or not, the 39-year-old thinks the Dancing With the Stars winner will not be sticking around on the pilot’s season.

“I don’t,” Nick said of whether he feels Hannah, 25, will stay and compete for the 28-year-old’s heart at the iHeartRadio Podcast Awards Presented by Capital One on January 17. “I feel like they got their closure, but I could be wrong.”

Hannah Brown and Peter had Something Between Them on The Bachelor
ABC/Eric McCandless

Everyone, including Nick, has been wondering how the almost-couple would fare after Hannah unexpectedly showed up on the leading man’s season. “Peter was definitely shocked,” an insider exclusively revealed to Life & Style after the episode aired. “When Hannah came out of the limo, I knew he was shaken up. He told me he respected Hannah for returning his wings that he gifted her on The Bachelorette, but once they sat down to have a conversation, it all started to hit him.”

“Going into filming, we spoke about how he closed that chapter of his life and he was moving on. So, to see her again it opened up a lot of old wounds,” the source continued about the intense encounter. “He said his feelings rushed back and he definitely needed a second to collect his thoughts — that’s why he canceled the rest of the group date. He also didn’t want to disrespect the other girls.”

Though seeing Hannah again really rocked Peter’s world, everyone is still curious about who is going to come out on top this season. When it comes to Nick’s predictions, he’s not sure. “It’s too early,” he revealed to LS. “I’ve only seen two episodes but I think obviously he likes Madison [Prewett] but it’s so early.”

Plus, he’s just as curious as you are about Chris Harrison‘s mystery role in the preview for the final rose. “I don’t know. I mean that can be anything, it might be like the score of a football game,” he explained. “When it comes to those previews you never know. I’m as curious as everyone. Everyone’s, you know, Peter’s daring people to find out the end, and none of us know.”

Guess we’ll just have to wait and see.