Wedding bells may be ringing sooner than Bachelor Nation planned, y’all. Bachelor star Colton Underwood and his season 23 winner Cassie Randolph have fans and followers speculating he may have put a ring on it already, despite the fact that the 23-year-old claimed she wasn’t quite ready to commit just yet.

The 27-year-old suitor posted a sweet photo of himself and his sweetheart at a Vegas Golden Knights game getting their snuggle on, which would normally just be a super cute photo and not much more. Except, of course, for this detail — the back of Cassie’s jersey reads “Future Mrs” where Colton’s reads “Underwood.” Um, sounds pretty telling to us.

colton-underwood-cassie-randolph-bachelor
Instagram

As if that wasn’t enough to get fans speculating, Colton also captioned the photo, “Future Mrs.” Are you trying to tell us something, Colt? We’re listening.

Naturally, Bachelor Nation followers flooded the comments section of the sneaky post to let the couple know their thoughts on the potential engagement. “OKAY I SEE YOUUUUU,” one fan wrote, while another chimed in, “My heart just exploded!” Same, girl.

Deal of the Day Blue Bathing suit 4-7-24

Deal of the Day

This ‘Slimming’ Suit is Just $16 Today! View Deal

But not everyone was convinced these two had seriously made the next step in their relationship, since Cassie had been so real about her stance on the milestone. “Yeah but she wasn’t ready to get engaged…” one confused follower commented, while another asked, “Wait, are they engaged now?”

Comments like “Interesting….” and “Does that mean he proposed?!” were almost as frequent as the well wishes and congratulations on the post, but one user summed it up best for the skeptics: “The point of the show is to find love and they did just that, sorry you hate it now.” Talk about a clap back!

As for Colt and Cass, the (possibly engaged and) happy couple seem to be enjoying a much needed vacay in Las Vegas, where they’ve been wining and dining with friends and family for a little weekend trip, according to their IG Stories. Enjoy yourselves, you two — whether or not you’re actually engaged. We can pray though!