We know one thing has been on your mind since The Bachelor premiere on January 6: Who does Peter Weber pick? Bachelor Nation has been warned to ~expect turbulance~ on the hunky pilot’s journey to find love, but that doesn’t mean he won’t find the right woman. Caution: Spoilers for season 24 are below. Do not keep reading if you don’t want to know what happens!

Peter and Chris Harrison keep teasing that this season will be different than any other because the ending is impossible to spoil. The current theory is that there are no hints about an engagement because there is technically no ending to spoil … yet.

The Bachelor Peter Weber Contestants FRONT ROW: SARAH, MADISON, LAUREN, TAMMY, DEANDRA, PETER WEBER, KIARRA, LEXI, JASMINE, MYKENNA, SYDNEYMIDDLE ROW: KELLEY, NATASHA, KELSEY, SAVANNAH, KYLIE, HANNAH ANN, KATRINA, COURTNEY, JADE, VICTORIA F.BACK ROW: ALEXA, EUNICE, AVONLEA, MAURISSA, MEGAN, PAYTON, SHIANN, VICTORIA P., ALAYAH, JENNA
ABC/Craig Sjodin

The show host even teased that “it’s possible it’s still not over,” during an interview with Good Morning America on January 5. Some fans think a proposal will happen on After the Final Rose while others hypothesize that the leading man left without getting down on one knee. Either way, leave it to ABC to keep us guessing.

However, the final two ladies are Hannah Ann Sluss and Madison (a.k.a. Madi) Prewett, according to Reality Steve. The final four also included Victoria Fuller (third place) and Kelsey Weier (fourth place).

Peter Weber Final Four the Bachelor
ABC (4)

Ahead of the season premiere, Peter did share a heartfelt message of gratitude about his journey, and it was definitely dripping in positive vibes. “It’s impossible for me to express how thankful I am for having the most amazing opportunity to find my girl,” he began his lengthy post. While he doesn’t specifically say he found Mrs. Right, his words do seem to be a hint in the right direction.

However, the pilot was also sure to thank the other contestants who uprooted their lives for a chance at love. “To every single woman that shows up tonight, thank you from the bottom of my heart for taking a chance on me,” he continued. “Through every high and every low, I had the time of my life getting to know you all and made memories I will cherish forever.”

We can’t wait to see what’s next!