Jeffree Star Dating History: Relationships, Ex-Boyfriends

If you were active on MySpace in the early 2000s, then you already know Jeffree Star has been famous for quite some time. That said, the popular YouTuber-turned-beauty-mogul has only had a handful of significant relationships during his time in the limelight.

In the early days of Jeffree’s fame, his love life was kept pretty low-key. However, in 2015, he began dating his now-ex Nathan Schwandt and the two quickly became one of social media’s cutest and most highly publicized couples.

For years, it looked like Jeffree and the Michigan native were in it for the long haul. Sadly, that all changed in January 2020. Less than two weeks after ringing in the new year together, Jeffree released an emotional, 17-minute video detailing the pair’s shocking split.

“There’s no easy way to say this but we did break up. Me and Nathan will be friends forever, I will always have love for him,” the Los Angeles native explained. “Are we in love with each other? No. But we love each other and he will always be in my life.”

Based on Jeffree’s explanation, it’s unclear exactly when he and Nate called it quits. “I’ve used a lot of this time of silence to just try to heal. We’re both in a state of shock. I’m devastated, I’m so sad,” he said. “And the love of my life is no longer … I don’t wake up to him anymore. He’s no longer here every morning and my routines have changed and I’m just in a state of shock right now. We both are.”

Deal of the Day

This ‘Slimming’ Suit is Just $16 Today! View Deal

After the former flames parted ways, Jeffree had a brief fling with Andre Marhold in summer 2020. However, as of January 2021, he appeared to be single again. The Wyoming resident seemed to find romance in January 2023, when he shared a mirror selfie holding hands with a mystery man while hinting that his potential new fling might play in the NFL.

Reps for Jeffree did not immediately respond to Life & Style’s request for comment.

Scroll through the gallery below to see a list of Jeffree Star’s ex-boyfriends and learn more about his dating history.

Andre Marhold

Jeffree and Andre first sparked dating rumors in August 2020 after the “Beauty Killer” artist uploaded a photo of himself straddling someone who appeared to be the professional athlete on Instagram. While Andre’s face was covered, fans recognized his tattoos. By September, Jeffree seemingly confirmed the pair’s split.

2023 Mystery Hunk

The Wyoming resident shared a mirror selfie on January 30, 2023, showing him holding hands with a very tall and well-built man who was only seen from behind. “His team didn’t make it to the Super Bowl but he’s 6’6 and plays perfect in the bedroom,” Jeffree gushed in the caption, hinting that his new fling might be an NFL player. Whoever his new guy is, the man sure is fashionable, as he was seen wearing a matching Louis Vuitton brown jacket and jeans.