Considering Evan Peters is one of the most talented (and cutest!) actors in Hollywood, it’s hard to believe he’s single. However, the American Horror Story star hasn’t publicly dated anyone since his split from girlfriend Halsey in March 2020.

Evan, 34, and the “Without Me” singer, 26, made their first public appearance in October 2019. They’re a very good match. Evan is not your typical L.A. actor, he’s from Missouri originally. She’s from New Jersey, and they have a lot in common,” a source told Life & Style at the time.

“They were both born to perform. Evan supports Halsey in everything she pursues,” the insider added. “They love just hanging around Hollywood, going to movies or just staying in and watching bad TV.”

Halsey and Evan Peters
Courtesy of Halsey/Instagram

Unfortunately, after only five months together, things came to an end! First, eagle-eyed fans noticed that the “Graveyard” artist deleted most of her Instagram photos Evan. Then, on March 22, 2020, it appeared as though Halsey and her ex-boyfriend Yungblud shared a meal together.

“My first crack at making a Sunday dinner. Supplies were limited,” she captioned an Instagram photo of her meal, which included the English delicacy Yorkshire pudding. “Can confirm,” Yungblud, who is from the U.K., teased in response.

Halsey has since moved on with boyfriend Alev Aydin and the pair are expecting their first child together.

Prior to dating Halsey, Evan’s most significant relationship was with his American Horror Story costar Emma Roberts. The former flames began dating in 2012 after meeting on the set Adult World.  “Everyone thought we dated on the movie and we didn’t … not for a long time after,” Emma revealed during an interview with Chelsea Handler in 2014.

“I actually, on the set, was like, ‘Oh yeah, we’re totally gonna date.’ And I would, like, flirt with him, which ended up looking like I had something in my eye because I’d be like, ‘Hey, what’s up?’ And he literally didn’t speak to me the entire movie,” she continued. “He thought I was so weird.”

By December 2013, Emma and Evan were engaged. However, in June 2015, the pair called things off. Eventually, they got back together, but their reconciliation didn’t last long. Evan and Emma split again in May 2016.

But wait … in September of that year, they gave things another shot before finally parting ways in March 2019. “Emma and Evan were heading for a split and now are just friends,” a source told Us Weekly at the time. “Evan has moved out. It wasn’t a bad breakup.”

Emma is now dating actor Garrett Hedlund. The lovebirds welcomed their first child together, a son named Rhodes, in December 2020.