Who will he choose? Peter Weber‘s final two Bachelor contestants may or may not surprise you, but he will definitely have a tough choice ahead of the finale. Caution: Spoilers for season 24 are below. Do not keep reading if you don’t want to know what happens!

In the end, the 28-year-old is left with contestants Hannah Ann Sluss and Madison Prewett in Australia, where the show’s finale was filmed. The brunette beauties were the pilot’s frontrunners all season — Hannah Ann was given the first impression rose and Madison went on the first one-on-one date. The last two ladies eliminated before decision day are Victoria Fuller (after overnights) and Kelsey Weier (after hometowns). This means we may be seeing them on Bachelor in Paradise soon. Fingers crossed!

Peter Weber Final 2 on The Bachelor Spoilers
ABC/Craig Sjodin

Peter’s season is unique because he and show host Chris Harrison both have been teasing that it’s impossible to spoil the ending. Although there is no clear winner in the spoiler universe yet, there are a few theories that the leading man will wait to propose or choose his winner until After the Final Rose. Of course, there is also a possibility that Peter is currently single, but he’s seemed very happy since his season wrapped, so it’s likely he found his girl.

He dished more details about his finale and why he’s confident it will be a surprise to viewers. “It’s just cool. It’s a unique thing and I think it’s fun if no one figures it out. Again, I didn’t go into this thinking, ‘Oh it’s going to be unspoiled.’ Again, I couldn’t have predicted what happened,” the stud explained to Ben Higgins and on the January 7 episode of the “Almost Famous” podcast.

So, who will Peter pick? Both ladies have found their way into his heart. “Hannah Ann was someone that … That girl knew exactly what she wanted coming into this and never let me question that,” Peter admitted on  and ‘s “” podcast on January 7. “And I literally mean that from the beginning. She was the first person to steal me away for the first conversation. She was the first kind of normal kiss. Not from like the first entrances. We clicked immediately.”

As for Madison, she met Peter’s entire family — including his sweet parents — during their first date. The pilot gushed over her “great energy” and the Alabama beauty immediately fit right in. “That was as perfect as I could’ve ever expected it to,” the Bachelor Nation stud told her after their day together.

Both ladies have a great chance at getting proposed to during the finale, but will Peter be willing to get down on one knee? Time will tell!