Who Will Be the Next 'Bachelorette'? Here Are the Top Picks

Now that Colton Underwood‘s journey to find love is winding down, people can’t stop wondering who will be the next lead on The Bachelorette. There are a lot of great contenders but the consensus is definitely split among fans. ABC should be announcing their decision any minute and we’re keeping our fingers crossed for an unforgettable choice. Keep scrolling to see the top choices below!

Deal of the Day

This ‘Slimming’ Suit is Just $16 Today! View Deal

Caelynn Miller-Keyes

Miss North Carolina is a strong choice among fans. She received a ton of praise after bravely sharing her sexual assault story. Although she was a major front-runner all season, she was sent packing after hometown dates and was devastated. Caelynn has a lot of positive traits but, as the season progressed, some people found her to be ingenuine and thought her only motivation was to be the next Bachelorette.

Hannah Brown

Another beauty queen! Miss Alabama didn’t crack the top four but fans adore her. After showing her quirky personality and fearsome roar, viewers found her to be very real and relatable. All 14 of the previous Bachelorettes finished within the final four of their season so Hannah will make history if she’s chosen.

There Were Rumblings About the Decision.

“Obviously, it’s possible things can still change last minute, but I don’t expect that to happen this time. Announcement will officially be made on the ATFR [After the Final Rose] next week, but I can report Hannah B. is gonna be your next Bachelorette,” Reality Steve tweeted about the Alabama native on March 4.

Hannah Godwin

Cute as a button and sugary sweet. The Alabama native has been showing more and more of her personality each week and people are loving it. She’s done a good job of staying above the drama so there’s really nothing negative to say about her. The only argument is that her season may play out a little dull because of her reserved personality.

Tayshia Adams

This one is a puzzler because we’ve seen a lot of different sides of the 28-year-old. On one hand, she’s proven to be super fun and adventurous. On the other, we saw her throw a few women under the bus this season which seemed unsettling. News also surfaced that she had a boyfriend right before she left to go on the show. Not a good look.

Kristina Schulman

Since most of the top contenders from Colton’s season are only 23, people seem to prefer an older lead to make it more believable that they’re ready for marriage. A lot of Bachelor Nation favorites are currently in serious relationships (Raven Gates, Tia Booth, Kendall Long), but Kristina would be a great throwback pick. After a tumultuous relationship with Dean Unglert in Paradise, she deserves the chance to find love.

Danielle Maltby

Another blast from the past. Danielle is a sweet neonatal nurse from Nashville who competed on Nick Viall‘s season and then appeared on Paradise with no luck. She was shockingly cheated on by her ex, Paul Calafiore. In December, the starlet opened up about being “terrified” to date again but has seemingly been doing a lot better in recent months. Give our girl a chance!