Not here for it! Bachelor Nation alum Jason Tartick thinks it’s time for Hannah Brown and Peter Weber “to move in their own direction” after their reunion on The Bachelor, the reality stud tells Life & Style exclusively. Fans watched as the former Bachelorette star returned (twice) on the pilot’s season during the first two weeks, and it ended in a tearful conversation where Hannah confessed that she has regrets ending things with Peter “all the time.”

Jason, 31, admits it was “endearing” to see Hannah, 25, step out of the limo on night one and return a set of airline wings that Peter, 28, originally gifted her. However, the boyfriend of show alum Kaitlyn Bristowe thinks that’s probably where it should have ended. When she returned for the leading man’s group date, Jason says he wonders “where is this going.”

ABC/John Fleenor

“It was interesting to see her frustration and crying in the back. I would love to hear her perspective of it because I’m still confused,” divulges Jason. “I don’t think her intention was to go back and get Peter, but I think what happened is all these feelings started manifesting. And, [in] my opinion, I think the conversation was had. She came back several times.”

Hannah and Peter seemingly ended their romantic chapter (for now), but some theories suggest that they end up together at the end. “I think that door is closed, and I think they should both move in their own direction and find happiness,” admits Jason. TBH, he’s probably not wrong.

Ben Higgins exclusively spoke with Life & Style on January 29 about who he ships the unattached Alabama beauty with from the Bachelor franchise. “You know what? I’m a big Derek Peth fan. I like Derek. . He’s been through a lot, too,” Ben said during a sit down with his Bachelor Live On Stage costar Becca Kufrin. “Also love Shawn Booth. I think they’re single Bachelor Nation people. As well as Nick Viall  — like all three of those. Put those guys up in a line and let her choose. I think they’d all do great.” As for who Peter ends up, Blake Horstmann joked that it might just be him and Chris Harrison standing at the end.

Peter and Hannah aren’t meant to be at the moment, but we think they’re both on their way to happiness!