Dumped From the Island! Who Went Home on ‘Love Island U.S.A.’ Season 4?

Valerie Bragg

Sadly, the first one to get dumped from the island was Val. While the tattooed beauty thought she turned Jesse’s head, his connection to Deb was ultimately stronger as he chose to couple up with the Dallas, Texas, native in the first elimination of the season. 

“I just feel like I was being lied to,” Val told Mady prior to her dumping on the Sunday, July 24, episode. “He was like, ‘I would pick you.’ He literally told me that yesterday. And now, I’m asking him, like, I’m applying pressure, so I’m like, ‘If we were coupling tonight, then what?’ … Right now, he’s like, ‘I guess, I’ll pick Deb then.’”

Tyler Radziszewski

The first boy bombshell was also the first to make his departure from the villa. Following the arrival of siblings Bria Bryant and Chazz Bryant, the Ohio native was left single after Chazz stole his partner, Sereniti, in a recoupling ceremony. 

Felipe Gomes

The former soccer player was dumped from the villa after his current partner, Courtney, chose to pursue a connection with new boy Bryce, leaving him single and on a flight home from Love Island U.S.A.

Andy Voyen 

After a public vote, two of America’s least favorite couples were vulnerable to elimination. The couples in the bottom two were Timothy and Bria and Andy and Mady.
 
The remaining boys were given the opportunity to save one boy at the bottom between Timothy and Andy and they opted to save Timothy.

Bria Bryant

As for the girl’s decision, they chose to save Mady and in turn, send Bria on a plane ride home.
 
“I still feel like there was unfinished business for me at the villa,” the New Jersey native confessed in her exit interview with producers. “I feel like I left too soon. I feel like under different circumstances the connection between Timmy and I would have worked out differently.”

Sereniti Springs

Following the arrival of three bombshells, connections in the villa were tested. Following a re-coupling ceremony, Chazz chose to pursue new girl Kat Gibson and send the Clovis, California, native packing. 

“He did what he was feeling and that’s what he has to do,” fellow islander Zeta said of Chazz choosing the stronger connection with the new islander over his current partner, Sereniti. “At the end of the day, he and Sereniti just weren’t suited for each other. It is unfortunate that she’s had to go home.”

Bryce Fins

In the final elimination before Casa Amor, America voted for their favorite islanders. The four least popular boys and the four least popular girls were deemed vulnerable for dumping. The boys with the least amount of the public’s votes were Chazz, Jesse, Bryce and new boy Jared. As for the girls, Mady, Courtney and new girls Kat and Nadjha were at risk of leaving the villa. 

Only two islanders would be sent home and the final decision was left up to the remaining saved contestants. The girls would decide which boy went home and the boys would make the decision for the girls. At the firepit, the girls ultimately chose to send Courtney’s current partner, Bryce, home. 

“She was expressing certain concerns and we just kind of had to like, listen to that,” Zeta explained to the California native. “And that’s the only thing we had to move off of and we felt like Jared just ain’t had his time in here.”

Mady McLanahan

While the boys had yet to reveal their ruling, Mady stepped up and announced her decision to voluntarily leave the villa. Since her previous partner Andy’s departure, the Texas native found it hard to make other romantic connections and gave the other girls the opportunity to find love in the villa. 

“Once Andy left, I just honestly, I haven’t been the same,” the blonde beauty confessed in her exit interview. “I wasn’t sure if I was going to find that same connection here in the villa.”

Tigerlily Cooley, Avery Grooms, Gabrielle Kiszka

Following their time at Casa Amor, Tigerlily, Avery and Gabriella failed to make a connection with the men in the villa.

Tre Watson, Jordan Morello, Sam Kornse

Unfortunately, Tre, Jordan and Sam didn’t turn heads in Casa Amor and were dumped from the island. 

Kyle Fraser

Deb’s partner left the villa for personal reasons. 

Nic Birchall

The Venezuela native ultimately felt there was nothing left for him in the villa after his partner, Nadhja, decided her connection with Jeff was stronger.

Bella Barbaro, Chazz Bryant, Chanse Corbi, Jared Hassim

Following the public’s vote, Bella and Chazz and Jared and Chanse were voted as America’s least favorite couples and therefore — dumped from the island.

Katherine Gibson

After coming back from Casa Amor alone, Kat realized her connection with Jared was the strongest. Following his dumping, she decided to leave with him. 

Courtney Boerner

While the brunette beauty returned from Casa Amor with Chad Bryant, upon their arrival in the villa, they realized they were on two different wavelengths. Courtney had been in the villa since day one and was ready to settle down with one person, meanwhile, Chad was just starting his Love Island journey and was open to exploring different connections. 

Mackenzie and Joel

Following the public’s vote, two couples were up for elimination. The girls were given the option to save one boy and the boys had the opportunity to save one girl. While the girls opted to save Chad and in turn send Joel home, Mackenzie volunteered her spot in the villa — thus saving Phoebe. 

Phoebe and Chazz

After Courtney’s departure, Chazz ultimately found the connection he was looking for in fellow Casa Amor bombshell, Phoebe Siegal. After being voted in the bottom two, the islanders opted to send the newest couple home. 

Nadjha and Jeff

Following the islander’s final vote, Jeff felt the remaining islanders were making their decisions on friendships, rather than actually the compatibility of the couples. The blowout caused an immediate argument with his partner Nadjha Day, leading to their departure from the villa.