If you haven’t started watching Nicole “Snooki” Polizzi and Nico Tortorella’s new show How Far Is Tattoo Far? then tonight is the perfect time to start! In an exclusive sneak peek ahead of the new episode, a mama’s boy named Garrett gets a HUGE tattoo on his back — personally selected by his girlfriend, Micah!

“Garrett, your mother is not going to like this tattoo,” the Jersey Shore co-host tells him. And it’s clear that Garrett is totally freaked out. He even starts crying hysterically before taking off his blindfold! It’s safe to say Garrett and Micah’s relationship could be in serious trouble after this. Watch the video above to see the shocking footage and don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube Channel.

Be sure to watch How Far Is Tattoo Far? every Thursday night on MTV at 9:00 p.m. ET!