Khloé Kardashian would rather eat a bloody fish eye than talk about her rumored father O.J. Simpson.

During an appearance on The Late Late Show with James Corden, the 32-year-old played the game Spill Your Guts or Fill Your Guts, which requires guests to consume rather disgusting delicacies if they refuse to answer a personal question.

MORE: Pregnant? Khloé Kardashian Wants a Baby Before Marriage With Tristan Thompson

Khloé, whose late dad Robert Kardashian Sr. served on O.J.’s legal team during his infamous 1995 murder trial, was forced to eat the eye after failing to answer James’ question, “Do you think O.J. did it?”

khloé kardashian o.j. simpson getty images

“It’s a real eye. I think there’s blood on that one,” the horrified reality star said. “Oh my god it f–king jiggles. I think I might throw up though. Oh my god it’s coming out. I have long nails, what do you want me to do? Fine dining. Thank you for inviting me,” she added, letting out a couple of screams before downing it like a champ.

It’s long been reported that Khloé is actually the daughter of the former NFL player, who’s currently in prison for armed robbery. In October, the fitness fiend joked about the speculation on Instagram. “I don’t know… Some days I’m O.J.’s daughter. Others I’m Robert’s daughter,” she said at the time.

MORE: Enter for a Chance to Win a Golden Globes Gift Bag Worth Nearly $600!

But in early 2016, the Strong Looks Better Naked author defended herself and her family against accusations from Robert’s widow, Jan Ashley, who claimed that her husband also questioned his daughter’s paternity. “[Jan] wanted to come out 10 years after my dad passed away and say I’m not my dad’s daughter. And he confided in her,” the former talk show host said. “I was like, ‘You can talk about me and my sisters all you f–king want. Do not talk about my dad.’”

Watch Khloé’s Late Late Show clip below!