Larry Caputo stood by wife and Long Island Medium star Theresa Caputo through thick and thin, as she herself said on the TLC reality show. So viewers were stunned when they announced their breakup in December — and desperate to learn what happened between these spouses of 28 years. Specifically, fans really to want to know if Larry cheated on Theresa!
Reassuringly, as we previously reported, there's no indication of infidelity between the two TV stars. But Theresa did have reason to worry on at least one occasion. As we saw in a 2013 episode of Long Island Medium, she had a dream she couldn't shake off. "I dreamt that Larry was having an affair," she said in that installment, per Radar Online. "And I'm like, 'Are you freaking kidding me? Seriously?'"
In the episode, Larry returns home to find Theresa fuming. "Where have you been? You're in big trouble!" she said. "What am I in big trouble about?" an oblivious Larry responded.
Theresa told Larry about her vision, and he laughed it off… Before revealing he had an eerily similar dream. "It's funny you mention that because I had a dream some girl was trying to hit on me," he said, smirking. "I knew it!" Theresa screamed.
Theresa was still concerned, so she asked Larry if he had ever thought about being with anyone else, and he said she was the only person he thought about. Then she gave him an ultimatum: Either he would go with her to marriage counseling or he would join her in dance lessons. He chose the latter.
So if Larry didn't have an affair, why did he and Theresa split? The 61-year-old gave us insight into their breakup in a December episode of Long Island Medium. "We're having a difficult time," he said. "I think a lot of the frustration has to do with us not spending the time together anymore. Along with that comes the lack of communication, so it's like losing your best friend. It's hard."
Larry added, "As much as I try to busy myself so I'm not thinking about it, it's still there. I know it's very trying for both of us. I don't want to make it just about me. I know it's the same for Theresa also."
So the story behind Theresa and Larry's split isn't as salacious as fans might think — it's just sad. Here's hoping these two can walk away from their marriage as friends, at least. We'll just have to wait and see as the new season navigates through their emotional split!