Aly Raisman Boyfriends: See the Gymnast's Dating History

Low-key love life! Olympic gymnast Aly Raisman keeps her romantic life extremely private, and her dating history is relatively short.

Deal of the Day

These ‘Cloud-Soft’ Sandals Are 53% Off Today View Deal

The Massachusetts native spent most of her teen and adult life training to compete at the highest level of gymnastics, writing a New York Times bestselling book and working as an advocate for sexual assault survivors, so it’s not surprising the athlete isn’t worried about putting her dating life out in the public.

Her most high-profile relationship was with former Bachelor Colton Underwood. The pair started dating in fall 2016, almost two years before the former football player went on to find reality TV fame, and they split the following summer.

Jamie McGill

Jamie asked Aly to the Needham High School prom in 2012. Since she was training for the Olympics, she was not able to attend school with her classmates, so prom was a super fun night for the pair.
Although these two were a rumored couple until the following year, Aly clarified to Us Weekly that they were “just really good friends.”

Colton Underwood

In 2016, Colton sent a congratulatory video to Aly through Yahoo! Sports where he extended an invite to take her out. She said yes, and they went on a double-date with athlete Andrew East and gold medalist Shawn Johnson.
Although Aly stayed hush-hush about their prior romance, Colton detailed their devastating breakup in his book, The First Time.

“Aly FaceTimed me and ended our relationship,” the Bachelor Nation star recalled. “I pulled over to the side of the road, stunned and unable to comprehend this was happening … Afterward, I sat in my car and cried. I was numb for days.” The six-time gold medal winner said at the time that “she felt overwhelmed, confused and in need of a break.”

“I reached out to Aly several times without getting any response to my calls or texts,” the former Bachelorette contestant continued. “I called Aly’s best friend, Simone Biles, hoping she could offer an explanation or insight. She couldn’t. She was also surprised. Left without any answers or information, I didn’t know what to do or where to turn. I went for long runs and replayed conversations in my head, wondering if I’d said or done anything wrong.”

Colton married Jordan C. Brown in 2023.

Chris Evans

Aly and the Knives Out actor sparked romance rumors in November 2020 when she shared a video of him playing with her dog. Chris brought his own rescue pup over for a playdate, but it seems the pair are just pals.
“We’ve been friends for a couple of years,” the Olympic athlete told Us Weekly in May 2021. “He’s great. He’s super nice.”

Aly’s puppy, Mylo, and Dodger, who belongs to the Marvel actor, are just as close with one another. “Our dogs have fun together, so it’s nice,” she gushed.

She Opened Up About Being Single

She opened up about being single in her 30s in a June 2024 piece for PopSugar.

“It’s wonderful if you’ve found your soulmate by the age of 30, but why shouldn’t it be just as celebrated and hopeful to be single and still figuring out who you are? I think the most important relationship we will have in life is with ourselves, and we should allow for the time and space for that to develop and flourish,” she wrote. “I am still on a path of self-discovery, and through that I’ve learned that I can want to find a life partner yet still love the experience of being single. Regardless of where I end up, being single will be a part of the process, so why not embrace it?”

Being Candid

Aly further discussed her dating life during a July 2024 appearance on the “Call Her Daddy” podcast.

“How often do we hear someone be like, ‘I just turned 30, and I’m feeling better than I have in a very long time.’ And I’m also, like, I’m OK with being single. Like, I’d rather be single and wait until I have a good match,” she said. “And I also feel like, as a woman, too, I don’t know if you ever struggle with this, with dating, but I felt like, as I got older, I have this. I’m like, I really hope that guys don’t perceive, just because they know my age that I’m, like, desperate or, like, you know, that, like, perception of, I hope they’re not thinking. I’m just, like, in a rush because I don’t have a timeline.”