Bachelor Nation’s Biggest Cheating Scandals: Look Back at All the Drama From Accusations to Hookups! 

Victoria Fuller

Victoria was rumored to have cheated on Johnny with Greg. Although Zachary Reality claimed she “never cheated on Johnny,” Victoria has not confirmed nor denied the allegations.

Erich Schwer

Although Erich seemingly broke things off with his former girlfriend, Amanda revealed he was still texting her in March 2022, seemingly implying that he missed her.

“I hate to play with your emotions,” he wrote in one message. “I just went home for a while, and I couldn’t stop thinking about you. I wanted to send you flowers to maybe make you smile.”

Clayton Echard

TikToker Sasha Narang claimed she had unknowingly hooked up with Clayton after he approached her at a bar. However, both Clayton and then-girlfriend Susie Evans publicly denied the story altogether.

“I can’t even believe I’m addressing this, this is ridiculous, but let’s just make this as easy as possible,” the Bachelor season 26 alum said via his Instagram Stories. “My video shows I was in an AZ gym at 8 p.m. MST, which is 11 p.m. EST (your time). So, even if I hopped right on a private jet, I wouldn’t make it to NY until 3:30 a.m. EST (flight from AZ to NY is 4 1/2 hours). So, that disproves you saw me at 2 a.m. EST.”

After Clayton and Susie slammed the allegations, the TikTok user apologized to the former couple.

“This guy truly convinced me that he was Clayton,” she shared. “He, again, introduced me to himself as Clayton. He told me he was on The Bachelor. He knew his hometown, his birthday — knew all these super weird facts that it just, obviously, in that moment, me not watching The Bachelor, knowing nothing about it, I believed him.”

Jed Wyatt

In July 2019, The Bachelorette’s Jed got engaged to Hannah Brown by the season finale. However, his ex-girlfriend Haley Stevens made some shocking allegations against him.

“We spent the night together the night before he headed to L.A.,” she told People at the time. “He told me [the show] was just an obstacle and we’d be stronger on the other side because of it.”

She also alleged that Jed told her he was only participating in the series to further his music career and promised that he would contact her after the show ended.

“He said, ‘It’s probably not going to happen, but it’s a huge opportunity,’” Haley continued. “’I’m only doing this for my music.’ He only did it for his career. He kept telling me, ‘I don’t want my dad to have to help me pay rent anymore.’ … I was following along on spoiler accounts, trying to figure out when my boyfriend was going to come home. I was terrified that he would fall in love with Hannah. I thought, my boyfriend could be engaged to someone else. Seeing him kissing her for the first time was the worst day.”

Despite Haley’s heartbreaking accusations, Jed came forward and denied cheating on either Hannah or Haley.

“No, I never cheated. Ever. On Haley or Hannah,” the former reality star wrote via social media.

Hannah and Jed split following the season finale. Hayley is now married to Hannah’s brother, Patrick Brown.

Jenna Cooper

Jenna got engaged to Jordan Kimball during the season 5 finale of Bachelor in Paradise. However, Reality Steve tweeted several screenshots of what appeared to be texts between Jenna and a “sugar daddy.” After she hired lawyers and forensic investigators to help clear her name. The BiP alum proved the messages were fabricated, and Reality Steve apologized for the “misstep.”

Nevertheless, Jordan broke up with Jenna shortly after their engagement aired on TV.

Robby Hayes

In September 2017, former BiP stars Amanda Stanton and Robby got into a social media back-and-forth over rumors that he allegedly cheated on her. Amanda’s friends Emily and Haley Ferguson accused Robby of being with another woman while at a Colorado concert.

“He did cheat on Amanda,” Emily claimed during the taping of the show. “There were pictures coming out.”

While Robby called the accusations “blatantly untrue,” Amanda shared one of the apparently incriminating photos of Robby making out with another girl, captioning it, “Look what you made me do.”

Peter Weber

During season 24 of The Bachelor, Peter’s ex-fiancée, Hannah Ann Sluss, discovered he had hooked up with Hannah Brown while the season was still airing. While he wasn’t exclusively with Hannah Ann at the time, the season finalist couldn’t help but wonder if Peter’s mind was on someone else when they got engaged.

Peter and Hannah B. got together just one month after he and Hannah Ann split, sparking curiosity among fans at the timing of their hookup. Not only that, but most fans also recall that he started dating fellow Bachelor Nation star Madison Prewett shortly after he and Hannah Ann ended their engagement.