It’s a no from him, dawg. Jimmy Kimmel said his wife wanted Cassie Randolph‘s sister, Michelle, to be the next Bachelorette but her boyfriend, Gregg Sulkin, isn’t into it. Considering they’re an absolutely adorable couple who seem happy together, we don’t blame him.

“Hey [Jimmy Kimmel] — love your show sir, but sorry, not happening,” the 26-year-old wrote on Instagram with a laughing face and heart emoji. He used the caption to accompany a selfie of the two loves smiling in a car while Michelle winked.

After the Bachelor finale on March 12, Colton Underwood and Cassie appeared on Jimmy Kimmel Live to talk about their tumultuous relationship on the show and where they are now. The host mentioned that his wife really wanted the 23-year-old’s sister to take the reigns on the newest season. When Cassie mentioned that Michelle, 21, was dating someone, Jimmy jokingly quipped, “Get rid of him!”

It looks like Gregg isn’t standing down that easily. The pair made things official in October 2018 and seem completely smitten with each other. “Thank you for coming into my life and making it better,” he wrote on Instagram when they first took things public. “I love you.”

The actor has obviously secured a spot in the Randolph family because he seems extremely close with Cassie. He’s been very outspoken about supporting her throughout her journey to find love. After she sent herself home before her fantasy suite date despite Colton professing his love for her, Gregg rallied to uplift the reality starlet.


“It’s incredible to see your journey of growth this season and discovery, all whilst eyeballs have been on you at all times, which is not easy in the slightest,” he commented on her Instagram page. “I know [Michelle] is insanely proud of you and so am I. You’ve been a class act. As always.”

Gregg is here to stay, people!