Not only was Carmen Electra's on-again, off-again boyfriend, musician Rob Patterson, 41, three months late with the star's birthday present, it turned out not to be worth the wait.
"He went on Craigslist and got her a used treadmill," an insider tells Life & Style. "Carmen was appalled. It wasn't even new!"
"When Carmen realized her boyfriend was serious about the gift, she was shocked and upset," says a pal.
Carmen, who turned 40 in April, lives with Rob even though the two called off their four-year engagement in May.
For more, pick up this week's issue of Life & Style Weekly, on newsstands now.
Photo credit: NBC; R/R