So, you’re saying there’s a chance? Tayshia Adams and John Paul Jones ended their relationship during the September 10 episode of Bachelor in Paradise after going on the cutest prom-themed date together. Fans were shook since they seemed completely smitten with each other, but the reality babe confessed that she didn’t think she would be able to fall in love with him as quickly as she needed to. Don’t stress, Bachelor Nation, there’s evidence that the two may actually be back together, despite their heartwrenching split. Caution: Spoilers from the Paradise finale are below!

Bachelor in Paradise finale full cast
ABC/John Fleenor

First things first, since JPJ and Tayshia broke up about a month ago IRL, the heartbreak would most likely still be very fresh. However, they are super friendly on social media. The stud posted their adorable prom pic together with the caption, “Yaaaaaaaas Queen.” Tayshia also wrote on Instagram, “It’s the little things that make me happiest … sunset walks, friends, laughter, going to Prom.”

The suspicious part isn’t that they have nice things to say about each other, it’s the fact that they don’t follow each other on the social media platform. Both contestants follow literally every other cast member this season, except each other. If you are cool enough to post loved-up photos and captions about your previous relationship, don’t you think you would OK enough to follow each other? What are they hiding?

If you’re not into reading between the lines on social media, Reality Steve reported that the pair will leave the reunion show as a couple. According to the gossip outlet, a clip will be shown during the finale that captures Tayshia going to JPJ’s house after filming to see if he has any interest in getting back together.

Although Tayshia pulled the plug on their relationship in Mexico, she later revealed to Entertainment Tonight that she doubted her decision at the time. “Honestly, I felt like I’d made a really big mistake letting someone go that genuinely cared about me, but also I knew that my heart wasn’t there, so I didn’t wanna lead him on or anything,” she said during the finale taping.

Tayshia Adams and Chris Harrison Bachelor in Paradise finale
ABC/John Fleenor

The former contestant from Hannah Brown‘s season admitted that he felt a lot of disappointment when their romance fizzled out. “It was very difficult in that moment. I was very skeptical of going to Paradise to begin with, and I just didn’t have a great experience romantically on The Bachelorette, so it really just kinda questioned the authenticity of everything,” he confessed.

Time will tell what happens between Tayshia and John Paul Jones!