Every Shady Thing Bachelor Peter Weber and Madison Prewett Said About Each Other

Fuzzy Details

Madi claimed on Kaitlyn Bristowe’s “Off the Vine” podcast on April 21 that Peter reached out to rekindle their relationship days before he was spotted in Chicago with Kelley. “He was, like, calling me and texting me being like, ‘I miss you, let’s get back together,’” Madi dished. “You were telling me how much you loved me and wanted to get back together and now you’re with the one person that was my best friend … It just feels a little hurtful.”

Called Out

Peter publicly slammed the claims Madison made during her appearance on Kaitlyn’s podcast. “You’d think you’d have a little more respect for the situation given we both know there’s more to the story,” the pilot wrote while tagging Madi on Bachelor Nation Scoop’s podcast.

Low-Key Shade

After Madi’s interview with Kaitlyn, the starlet “liked” a bunch of tweets from fans supporting her side of the story. “I’m team [Madison Prewett] any day,” one user wrote with a hundred points emoji. Another person noted that the starlet “doesn’t need to explain herself.” 

Doomed From the Beginning?

Although Madi said to Kaitlyn she wished she would have been “apologetic” to Peter’s mom, Barbara Weber, during their explosive encounter on After the Final Rose, she pointed out that the tense situation set them up for failure.
“For that opportunity to kind of be taken from the both of us … for that to be the ending of the season, I mean I walked off that stage and I had never cried harder in my life,” she said. 

The Truth Comes Out

That’s not to say Madi thought she and Peter were a perfect match. “I didn’t disagree with some of the things she was saying,” the Alabama babe explained about Barb pointing out that the reality couple had nothing in common and saying they were not going to work out. “I saw all of the differences she was pointing out, as well, and honestly agreed with them.” 

Barb’s Moment

Peter also said his mom was “right” during an appearance on Ben Higgins and Ashley Iaconetti’s “Almost Famous Podcast” on April 8. He acknowledged that he and Madi “just weren’t compatible for each other.”

Ex-Besties

Madison said she and Kelley were “best friends” during and after filming The Bachelor, which made the situation between the lawyer and Peter sting even more.
“With just things that we had talked about and things that she had said to me about Peter — and about me and Peter and about her and Peter — and all that. It was really confusing to me when I saw all that, and I don’t know, that I didn’t receive any kind of like a heads up or any sort of, you know, a text or explanation of why,” Madi told Kaitlyn. 

What Is the Truth?

Madi also claimed she confronted Peter before their split about the rumors surrounding him and Kelley. “I think it’s very interesting because his answers and her answers very much contradict the current situation that’s happening right now. But, you know, it is what it is,” she divulged.

We See You!

Madison and some other contestants from season 24, including Kelsey Weier, Tammy Ly and Mykenna Dorn, teamed up for the “Pass the Brush” TikTok challenge. “Where’s Kelley?” a curious fan asked in the comments. “With our ex LOL,” Madi quipped. 
She later backtracked her statement in a comment on Bachelor Nation Scoop’s Instagram. “Lollll it was just a joke!!! No shade. All the love for them both,” she wrote. 

Boy, Bye

Madi and Hannah Ann publicly proved they were over Peter’s antics when they went on Instagram Live together on April 2. “I’m so glad that we have reconnected,” Madi gushed to the pilot’s former fiancé. 

Lesson Learned?

Peter said his experience with Hannah Ann and Madison is giving him a different approach when it comes to his relationship with Kelley.
“I just had an engagement that didn’t work out. I just was trying to pursue things with another woman that didn’t work out. That’s why right now, I’m just taking it really, really slow,” he said on Nick Viall’s “The Viall Files” podcast on April 7. Slow and steady wins the race, right?

Clearing the Air

Now that Peter is happily dating Kelley, he wanted to set the record straight on what *really* went down with Madi following the finale.

“To be straight up … we didn’t even get in a relationship again,” he told Entertainment Tonight in July. “I know they say, ‘Oh it’s 24 or 48 hours. That was the shortest relationship ever!’ We never committed to a relationship.” He added, “I think some people think that we got back together. We never were back together.”